Showing posts with label Indian Classical Music. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian Classical Music. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 12, 2017

The Music of Kishori Amonkar: a divine intervention


One of the legends that has over the years engrained itself as part of Indian music culture and its rich heritage is that of Emperor Akbar and his court musician Mian Tansen. For centuries together children of almost every generation have grown up listening to stories about this great singer. Such was his command over music that his renditions of certain ragas would lit lamps or bring rain. Although it is difficult to separate the fact from fiction, these stories did make an impression on my mind as a child. Years later I came across another one and this in many ways helped me understand the subtlety as well as the magnanimity of Indian classical music. This story had three characters, Emperor Akbar, Mian Tansen and his guru Swami Haridas.

For those of who don’t know about this story; Emperor Akbar once wondered if his favorite musician Tansen can sing so well, how much better would his guru’s music be. He insisted on listening to Swami Haridas and out of no choice Tansen relented. But only on a condition that they both will travel to Swamiji’s ashram and listen to him during his riyaaz. A few days later, when both of them heard Swamiji in his riyaaz, Akbar was so enthralled that he went speechless. On the way back from the ashram, Akbar had another question for Tansen; despite the fact that I love your music, why is it so that your music is so different than your guru’s? To this he replied saying, the answer is quite simple; I perform for you, but my guru performs for no one but the divine. And that makes all the difference.

I do not own rights for this image. If any concerned individual or an organization has an objection to this image used here, kindly notify me and I’ll promptly pull it down.
I suppose this is exactly what sets apart the music of Gaan Saraswati Kishori Amonkar. Throughout her life, she refused to play to the gallery and her music continued to grow more intuitive and inwards, almost like she was in a constant dialogue with the divine. And as an audience if one got a glimpse of it, it is to be treasured for the rest of the life.

I have been lucky to have met her, spoken with her and be in her presence at a few occasions if not many. For an artist of her stature, everyone who has heard her even once would have an understanding of what made her music so special. For me, her music led us into a state of fanciful imagination and reflective emotions. This brief note is about how I perceive her music purely from a standpoint of a listener.

Many of you would have attended her live concerts, and if you would recall she always insisted on performing the first rendition as per her wish. After that she would be open to accept requests, if any from listeners or organisers. I was listening to a live concert recording of hers on YouTube recently, and she’s heard talking to the audience saying although the performer before her had presented raga yaman, she would also be rendering the same raga as that is what is in her heart right now and she has to express it. Such was her sincerity that no conventions were ever important to her than to follow her heart.

As a performer she strived to get to the root of the emotion of the raga itself, to create an atmosphere through her music to touch the inner soul, the divine. Now while music is universal, the meaning of music is not. The meaning of music differs from person to person and it largely depends on the way one perceives it. Kishoritai helped bridge this gap. Her music was so finely blended with emotions, that most often her listeners were not listening to say raga yaman but to the feeling (bhava) that is raga yaman. No wonder then Tai’s mehfils have been only one of its kind, leaving the audiences spellbound for days even.

I do not own rights for this image. If any concerned individual or an organization has an objection to this image used here, kindly notify me and I’ll promptly pull it down.
The mahaul she created with each of her renditions was in the making even before she would start singing. Because a bhaav is a combined effect of swar, laya, taal, raga and bandish. As a listener in the audience, I have always been in awe of her attention to detail to all the possible aesthetics accompanying the swar. For instance her baithak with the accompanying artists on stage. Her tanpuras would be placed exactly equidistant at an arm’s length, pointing precisely at the same angle from her. And the tabla, violin and harmonium players would be sitting perfectly to complete the semi circle. For all these long years, although she had performed with many accompanists this setting would never change. The stage always appeared as a complete picture, there was nothing that was out of sync; thus nothing at all to distract the listener from soaking in the pure notes of music.

I do not own rights for this image. If any concerned individual or an organization has an objection to this image used here, kindly notify me and I’ll promptly pull it down.
Since her demise last week, many artists, her contemporaries and disciples among them, musicologists, renowned individuals from different fields have penned down their memories and how they interpreted the music and the personality of Kishori Amonkar. It is fascinating to see just how her music, unblemished from any forms of non-classical or popular cultural influence has touched such a wide audience transcending vocations as well as generations. It is a consolation that in the harried times of today, we had a musician like her amongst us whose renditions brought upon calm and peace. As the years will go by, we the listeners would be considered lucky as Emperor Akbar even to have lived in the times of great music.

Tuesday, February 16, 2016

Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music - 05 of 06

Following is the flow of the fifth of six part special, Rasa & Bhava in Music:

- snippet of tere mere sapne ab ek rang hain (Guide,1965)
- A single raga can evoke diverse feelings and thus we discuss compositions where two or more bhaav are used in varying proportion
- Understanding rasa in Indian music
- How does one rasa give way to another like shringar to hasya, raudra to karuna, veera to adbhuta and bibhatsa to bhayanaka?
- How audiences experience and enjoy the dominant mood (sthayi-bhava) created by various bhava and abhinaya in a composition. This experience, which is possible only through mental perception is termed as natyarasa.
- What happens when we blend two dominant moods together in a single composition?
- To explain this in detail, we take raga nand as an example - traditionally, raga nand stimulates shaant rasa and can float into shringar as well karuna rasa. So we will listen to raga nand in three different forms with varying proportions of shringar and karuna rasa.
- snippet of tu jahan jahan rahega mera saaya (Mera Saaya,1966)

Hope you enjoy listening to the show, Bollywood Rewind: Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music (05 of 06) –

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xrNqVfnq8qk


I do not own rights for the songs and the visuals used in this video. If any concerned individual or an organization has an objection to the music or visuals used here, kindly notify me and I’ll promptly pull it down.

Thursday, February 4, 2016

Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music - 04 of 06

Bollywood Rewind is a one-hour special segment series that's played every Sunday morning between 8am to 9am on Bahrain's only Indian Radio Station - 104.2 Your FM. It discusses the influence of Indian Classical and Folk music in the vintage era of Hindi Film industry. You can tune-in to listen to the station live at http://tunein.com/radio/1042-YOUR-FM-s178828/

This segment has been extremely popular with the audiences since it started airing in August 2014 and I have been happy to be a part of this journey with the morning show hosts, Hemang and Neeti. Although Bollywood Rewind as the name suggests is broadly based on music from the Hindi Film industry; in each episode we select a topic and try to dig deep into various cultural and artistic influences that would have inspired the popular music of yesteryears in India. Although the show is in Hindi, we use a significant amount of English in our conversation for the benefit of those listeners who are not extremely comfortable in Hindi.

Last month, for the first time I posted links of an episode of Bollywood Rewind on this blog, the first three of the six-part special, Rasa & Bhava in Music. In short, rasa & bhava are the fundamental ingredients that form the true essence of music, where the performer and the audience fuse into one.

To keep it simple and easy to understand, the conversation has been essayed from the perspective of a performer vis-à-vis from the audience’s point of view and references have been used from classical music than popular music.

Following is the flow of the fourth of the six-part special, Rasa & Bhava in Music:

- snippet of madhuban mein radhika (Kohinoor, 1960)
- Explaining how some compositions express a bhava that does not match the primary rasa of the raga – like, a particular composition which is a veer-rasa-pradhan raga has the potential in its swar-sangati to evoke the veer rasa in the mind of the listener. But this cause-and-effect relationship cannot be applied every time without conditions.
- This is because a bhava is created out of aesthetics accompanying the creation of the swar and music therefore is only the combined effect of swar, laya, taal, raga and bandish. Together it creates a beautiful mahaul.
- While music is universal, yet the meaning of music is not universal. The meaning of music differs from person-to-person as it largely depends on one’s perception. Musicians usually consider their own music to be good quite simply because they understand it. If the listener is unable to understand it, he may not like it, even though it may be good. This is what I would call the ‘mental make-up. And this mental make-up plays an important role in appreciating music.
- A swar has no independent identity. It is identified always in relation to something. Standing alone, we do not know whether it is a dhaivat or a pancham. It is only with respect to a particular shadja that you can identify a dhaivat or a pancham or any other swar in the saptak.
- Similarly, when it comes to language; alphabets do not come with a pre-conceived emotion. Like A, B or C, they doesn’t mean anything. But words do. Sentences do.
- snippet of nainon mein badra chaaye(Mera Saaya, 1966)

Hope you enjoy listening to the show, Bollywood Rewind: Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music (04 of 06) –

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fe0hRE3Kb_4



I do not own rights for the songs and the visuals used in this video. If any concerned individual or an organization has an objection to the music or visuals used here, kindly notify me and I’ll promptly pull it down.

Thursday, January 28, 2016

Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music - 03 of 06

Following is the flow of the third of the six part special, Rasa & Bhava in Music and in this link; we discuss in detail the duality factor in Indian classical music:

- snippet of baadal ghumad badh aaye (Saaz, 1997)
- explaining the duality factor in Indian classical music
- Musicologist Sharangdeva’s theory of co-relating of rhythm and rasa
- Tabulation of using the correct tempo to convey the desired emotion
- How a different rasa can be created utilizing dynamics like volume levels
- snippet of abhi na jao chhod-ke (Hum Dono, 1961)

Hope you enjoy listening to the show, Bollywood Rewind: Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music (03 of 06) –


I do not own rights for the songs and the visuals used in this video. If any concerned individual or an organization has an objection to the music or visuals used here, kindly notify me and I’ll promptly pull it down.

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music - 02 of 06

Following is the flow of the second of the six part special, Rasa & Bhava in Music:

- snippet of dekha ek khwab (Silsila, 1981)
- Nav-rasa: what are the 9 rasas? What does each rasa mean?
- Rasas other than the ones mentioned in Nav-rasa
- How does one apply a rasa to a composition?
- Musicologist Sharangdeva and his interpretation of the Rasa Theory in Sangeet-Ratnakara.
- Theory about how each note carries its own scope of emotions with it.
- How the mood or bhava of a raga is dictated by the dominant notes in it, which would impart their emotional color to the melody.
- snippet of naina barse rim jhim (Woh Kaun Thi, 1964)

Hope you enjoy listening to the show, Bollywood Rewind: Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music (02 of 06) –


I do not own rights for the songs and the visuals used in this video. If any concerned individual or an organization has an objection to the music or visuals used here, kindly notify me and I’ll promptly pull it down.

Thursday, January 14, 2016

Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music - 01 of 06

Bollywood Rewind is a one-hour special segment series that's played every Sunday morning between 8am to 9am on Bahrain's only Indian Radio Station - 104.2 Your FM. It discusses the influence of Indian Classical and Folk music in the vintage era of Hindi Film industry. You can tune-in to listen to the station live at http://tunein.com/radio/1042-YOUR-FM-s178828/

This segment has been extremely popular with the audiences since it started airing in August 2014 and I have been happy to be a part of this journey with the morning show hosts, Hemang and Neeti. Although Bollywood Rewind as the name suggests is broadly based on music from the Hindi Film industry; in each episode we select a topic and try to dig deep into various cultural and artistic influences that would have inspired the popular music of yesteryears in India. Although the show is in Hindi, we use a significant amount of English in our conversation for the benefit of those listeners who are not extremely comfortable in Hindi.

This is the first time that I am posting a link to an episode of Bollywood Rewind on this blog, and I couldn’t think of any other show than the 6-part special, Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music. In short, rasa & bhava are the fundamental ingredients that form the true essence of music, where the performer and the audience fuse into one.

To keep it simple and easy to understand, the conversation has been essayed from the perspective of a performer vis-à-vis from the audience’s point of view and references have been used from classical music than popular music.

Following is the flow of the first of the six part special, Rasa & Bhava in Music:
- snippet of nazar lagi raja tore bangle par (Kala Pani, 1958)
- Introduction of the theme: what is it that sets a mood in a particular composition?
- Indian classical music is based on four pillars – sur, raga, taal and laya. But the spirit of classical music lies in the journey where the performer and the audience fuse into one; and this journey is rasa. The attainment of this purity is of utmost importance in Indian classical music.
- What is rasa?
Rasa is an ancient Indian Sanskrit word that is better experienced than read to clearly understand. It denotes a state of mind that brings about an emotional theme in a work of art. The portrayal of this emotional theme, leads us to understand bhava.
- What is bhava?
It is bhava that makes us differentiate between a sad and a happy song, or a romantic and a playful song and so on and so forth. It is the road that leads our mind into a state of imagination and sentiments producing an emotional change - rasabhava.
- What exactly makes an individual's music his own?
snippet of cham cham naachat aayi bahar (Chhaya, 1961)

Hope you enjoy listening to the show, Bollywood Rewind: Rasa & Bhava in Indian Music (01 of 06) – 


I do not own rights for the songs and the visuals used in this video. If any concerned individual or an organization has an objection to the music or visuals used here, kindly notify me and I’ill promptly pull it down.

Friday, October 18, 2013

I'm dancing at the feet of my lord, all is bliss all is bliss!

I would still like to believe that this was a typical habit of all the children back in the late 80s, to go through their dad's things when nobody's watching. Today when I look back, those episodes seem quite amusing dipped in sheer innocence. With no intention to come across something dramatic, there used to be this surge of excitement to know more about your father; and it rarely mattered if that something made any sense even. My father was an advertising professional and his study although impeccably tidy was quite a potpourri of sorts; filled with books, fancy magazines, newspaper cuttings, stencil drawings, long calligraphy pens, paper samples, colour bottles, paint brushes, music cassettes, old photographs, post-its, a magnifier lens in a leather pouch and a world of random things. Going through his desk was was like peeping through his thought bubble and wondering the endless possibilities that one can create by mixing any of the three things together. And so I used to sit and wonder, each thought happily spiralling into another, innocent imaginings I would say but like in a children's fairy tale there used to be a villanous thought buster as well - my dad's visiting card!

The designations mentioned on all the other visiting cards lying on the desk always made sense to me but not his. Unlike a Marketing Director or a General Manager or a Chairman his visiting card mentioned his designation as a Creative Director. And I was always puzzled what does this really mean. Like, what does he do at work the whole day that keeps him busy through the week and mostly weekends as well. Now if you ever happen to read the technical definition of creativity, it states creativity as a process of producing something that is both original and worthwhile. What is produced can come in many forms and is not specifically singled out in a subject or area. Obviously a young mind of mine then was in the midst of utter befuddlement. So I started having my own ideas about 'creativity' and about 'creative people'.


Shakti at a live performance
For me, being 'creative' was about doing something your way, starting a new trend and being recognised for it. And with that definition a lot of iconic people started featuring in my list. The list was quite a long one as it included all the names that I had come across while going through my dad's desk - Satyajit Ray, Kahlil Gibran, Ravi Shankar, V S Gaitonde, Kumar Gandharva, Bach, Edward De Bono, P L Deshpande and many more. But to be honest, these were mere names; I didn't know who they were nor did I know what did they really do. But as is the case ever so often, there was an exception. In this list of creative people, there also featured a music cassette and I exactly knew why was it on the list. I used to play this cassette endlessly on the loop and gather such joy every time I heard it. The sound of the bow instrument especially gave me goose bumps as a kid. And I was dead sure these musicians were super super creative. To my luck, I was not proven wrong, the album was a concert recording of an Indo-Western music group and I later found out the four group members were mavericks in the music world. The group was Shakti and the members of course were John McLaughlin, Zakir Hussain, Vikku Vinayakam and the one to whose music I was hypnotically attracted to, the ever-so innovative, the creative mastermind, L Shankar.

L Shankar
Laxminarayana Shankar was born to be a musician; not because he was the youngest of the six children in a family completely devoted to music for generations, but because of the sheer inquisitiveness that he had about music. The unquenched thirst to do something new, breaking the strict barriers of traditional music yet staying true to the discipline that offered him the platform to innovate, compulsively collaborate and daring to create something so unique that by the time you fathom, all you remember is his genius. 

A violinist, singer, composer and producer, L Shankar has worn many hats in his career of over 40 years and has managed to sell over 10 million album copies. An acclaimed master of improvisational music, he is a rare virtuoso who embraced distinct genres making his music a conflux of Indian music and World music with a blend of pop, rock and contemporary jazz. In one of his interviews, he was quoted saying, 'I would like to bring the East and the West together. That, I think is my role'. 

L Shankar's father V Laxminarayana Iyer was one of the most celebrated violinists of his times and his mother was a singer and a Veena player. So it was not a surprise that Shankar's musical training started from the age of two and he gave his first public performance just five years later.  His elder siblings are musicians as well including two world renowned violinists, Dr. L Subramaniam and late L Vaidyanathan. As a child, Shankar's training was not restricted to a specific idiom of music as his father was open to all kinds of music - Carnatic Classical, Hindustani Classical and other western musical styles. This surely laid the foundation stone for Shankar to combine the musical traditions of Southern India with world influences in violin and vocals both. Interestingly, Shankar not only managed to blend various musical styles but also bridge diverse cultures through his extensive collaborations with musical giants across the world.

After completing his BS in Physics in India, he moved to the US in 1969 and earned a Ph.D in Ethnomusicology from Wesleyan University in Connecticut. It was during this phase when he spent most of his time combining music styles of the East and the West. And it was here where he met John McLaughlin who was then studying the ancient Indian instrument Veena. They both took an instant liking to each other and decided to form a group, Shakti roping in Vikku Vinayakam and Zakir Hussian on Ghtam and Tabla respectively. Their first performance was held at South Hampton College on July 5, 1975. The recording of this concert was later released as their debut album in 1976. And since then, the group went to produce some of the most striking sounds in Indo-Western fusion for audiences world over. Shakti released two other albums in later years, Natural Elements and A Handful of Beauty. But with each member getting busy with their own exhaustive tours and schedules, the group dissolved by 1978. Interestingly though, each of these musicians stayed close to the musical style that had been pioneered during the 'Shakti' days.  According to Shankar, 'such experimentation and experience are more in depth than any college, unless you are studying in guru-shishya paramara, on a one-to-one basis.  

Double Violin
I have been listening to Shankar for years now, and whenever I do, there is this feeling that tells me he must be quite a dreamer. But then someone has said it quite rightly, those who dream, seek! Shankar's ultimate foray into musical innovation and experimentation has been the invention of the ten-string double-necked stereophonic violin. This instrument was conceptualised and designed by Shankar and built by guitar builder Ken Parker. The most distinguishing feature of the double violin is that it gives a single player the five and a half octave range of a full string orchestra, including double-bass, cello, viola and violin. The instrument in more ways gave Shankar greater flexibility as an instrumentalist. He introduced the unique sound of this instrument on his first solo album, Touch Me There in 1980. In the late 70s, Frank Zappa had replaced Jean Luc Ponty with Shankar on the electric violin for a short period but this stint had paid off Shankar quite well. Impressed with his talent, Frank Zappa produced and contributed lyrics for Touch Me There.

After the success of his debut album, Shankar continued to impress audiences and critics alike with his unmistakable sound through various albums and concerts. This also includes the 1996 Grammy nominated album Raga Aberi with his own Indian group featuring Zakir Hussain and Vikku Vinayakam. Over the years, he has literally perfomed alongside the who's who of the music industry - Peter Gabriel, Yoko Ono, Elton John, Eric Clapton, Phill Collins, Bruce Springsteen, Van Morrison, Sting among the wide array of pop stars; Ravi Shankar, Palghat Mani, Jan Garbarek, A R Rahman, Trilok Gurtu and many others from the World and Indian music genre. The list of collaborations and performances by Shankar is quite endless but what really makes his music stand apart from the rest is his philosophical approach to music. In one of his interviews, he said ' We should never be so busy that we cannot pray, dance, write, sing or do whatever we are destined to do.' In recent years, Shankar has been performing and touring extensively with Gingger Shankar and has been receiving rave reviews for the same. 
I just hope we all get to listen to more of his music in coming years as we come across musicians like him quite rarely and far between.

Saturday, September 28, 2013

HCM's best kept secret: Mallikarjun Mansur


In life, there are incidents that you don't want to forget and then there are incidents etched in your memory so vividly that every time you reflect upon them, they come out as fresh as you had remembered them to be. You grow with it, and as you do its memory opens up newer perspectives, dimensions, thoughts that had not crossed your mind yet. So the same incident gets an all-new meaning in your head; only until you remember it again. Nostalgia is such a spiral, but talking about incidents that have left lasting impressions on my memory, I remember many many years ago that one late afternoon when my dad's friend Bal Deshpande had visited our home. 

As an unwritten law, be it any time of the day we would always have some music playing in the background at home; the naad of the electronic tanpura at the least. Dad maintained it gave a certain continuity to your thoughts. But that day, our home was reverberating a little too loudly compared to the other days as my dad had bought me a cassette of Trilok Gurtu's brand new album African Fantasy. Excited obviously, I had been playing it on the loop from the time it was gifted to me. And I was in no mood to switch the cassette player off once the guests arrived. As a fair gesture, when the doorbell rang I voluntarily turned the volume down by half.

Now I will tell you why are all these details so important to the incident. Dinki Puriya is one of the tracks on African Fantasy, and as it started playing in the background both my dad's and Bal kaka's face lit up. Grabbing the moment, I pumped up the volume. Dinki Puriya is a beautiful acoustic track, packed with zesty sitar and powerful tabla accompaniment. Towards the end of the composition, Bal kaka started mentioning that it was such a treat these days to listen to ragas like these. Until then, I had not known that dinki puriya is actually a raga. Well, that was the smaller of the two revelations I experienced that day. 


As they continued discussing about rare complex ragas and artists who performed these with utmost finesse, Bal kaka said 'he neither had an imposing voice nor a grandiose stage personality but what a rare gem of an artist he was!' I had not heard about this artist until then, so asked dad to suggest a few recordings that I can listen to. Out of the many albums he pointed out, I selected raga bhimpalasi and once it started playing; a new world opened up in front of me. I discovered something new that day, the best kept secret of Hindustani Classical Music was now upon me. And that's how I was introduced to the music of Mallikarjun Mansur.



Of the many felicitations attributed to him like the doyen of Hindustani Shastriya Sangeet or the last of the purists; Mallikarjun Mansur was an artist, truly one of its kind. A towering personality, that was a sublime combination of humility and eminence. Born in 1910 in a village named Mansur near Dharwad in Karnataka, Mallikarjun went on to become one of the most celebrated singers of Hindustani Classical Music. His story is that of a genius who chose to live his life as a sadhak (disciple) of music. 

Since the age of ten, stage has been Mallikarjun's best companion. Starting as an actor-singer in musical plays in Karnataka, he soon gained popularity and built a repertoire of khayal, natyasangeet and bhajans. He had his first commercial release in 1933 and thus the ball had been set rolling. But the journey was not an easy one and the main reason for this was that until 60, Mallikarjun spent his life fulfilling commitments with All India Radio and HMV in Dharwad. Thus he was unable to create a following of national stature in the prime of his life through concert performances and tours across the country. But thanks to his disciplined lifestyle, he went on to perform for over 20 long years post his retirement. During this phase, not even once had anyone a slightest doubt of he being physically unfit to perform.

In my view, 'the meeting of the two oceans' is an analogy that best descrbes the music of Mallikarjun Mansur - his gayaki represented two gharanas, Gwalior and Jaipur Atrauli. And it was through this amalgamation that he carved out a style, so beautiful, complex yet intrinsically delicate that can be called only his. Although trained under these two gharanas, his true musical identity blossomed under the tutelage of three gurus - Neelkanthbuwa Alurmath (Gwalior Gharana), Manji Khan and Burji Khan (sons and disciples of Alladiya Khansaheb, founder of Jaipur-Atrauli Gharana). His reverence for his three gurus has been paramount in his life. He regarded them as perennial rivers of music that he could not draw enough from. 

While studying under Manji Khan, Mansur honed his technique to visualise the raga where each sur (note) seamlessly blends into the other, and while doing so how one can change the tempo within the same time cycle - making the raga, tala and laya a single unified body. As was the practice in a typical Gurukul parampara, a single raga was taught over days but every time it assumed a new form; this gave Mansur the impetus to think, ponder, debate over each composition and what emotions does it stir; thus understanding how the same raga with the same set of notes performed at different times can emit different feelings. It was during this apprenticeship that he mastered the Dhrupad-based style of Alladiya Khansaheb and built a wide repertoire of ragas including some rare and complex compositions, the unique characteristic of the gharana. Even at forty, Mansur frequently visited Kolhapur to continue his music lessons until Burji Khan passed away in 1950. In his autobiography Nanna Rasayatre, Mansur talks very candidly about his gurus saying that they continue to guide and inspire him in spirit, enabling him to understand the true meaning of music. Not surprisingly then, he had dedicated his success and the reputation he had gained to his gurus.

When you listen to Mallikarjun Mansur, there is an unmistakable string of authority and beauty in each performance; then be it raga yaman or a twin raga like basanti kedar or a complex one like khat. He would often cast a spell on his audiences with the purity of each note and the virtuosity to stitch together varied emotions of the bandish (lyrics) and thus revealing the individual beauty of each raga. Some say, he brought along a special intensity to his singing, an urgency and earnestness in the treatment of the melody. As admired for his Khayal renditions, Mansur was also notably popular for Natyasangeet and Bhajans in Kannada and Marathi both. Musicologists maintain that the one feature that stands out most uniquely in Mansur's style is the way his compositions grip the audience almost instantaneously. With no slow build-up in the form of an alap, the composition directly jumps to the bandish with the accompaniment of tabla. And this direct, dramatic feature of the performance helps establish a rapport with the listeners immediately. 

He was indeed a musical phenomenon and they say he didn't stop performing until his last day. He passed away in 1992 and thus an era came to an end. He was conferred with many titles and awards including Padma Vibhushan, Kalidas Sanman, Karnataka State Sangeet Academy Award and many others although no award would match his selfless service to music. There would be no one like him again but his music will surely continue to inspire scores of Hindustani Classical music lovers for years to come.

Thursday, May 19, 2011

One of the most Controversial Rivalries in HCM: Vilayat Khan & Ravi Shankar


Vilayat Khan with Ravi Shankar
If you have ever come across talking to someone from the Hindustani Classical Music circles, you would have heard about the perceived rivalry between two of the greatest Sitar players of the last century, Ravi Shankar and Vilayat Khan. While one was known for his elegance and presentation, the other had quite a reputation of being unpredictably brash and outspoken. I've heard  a lot of incidents involving the two maestros and how abhorrence often transpired between the two. But these stories seem more like a legend for the lack of finer details and clarity of reasoning.

I happened to read about an incident that took place in Delhi in 1950 where both Ravi Shankar and Vilayat Khan shared the stage along with Ali Akbar Khan and Kishan Maharaj. And if that was not all, legendary musicians like Allaudin Khan (Ravi Shankar and Ali Akbar Khan’s guru), singer Amir Khansaheb were seated amongst other dignitaries in the audience. It was here when things took a turn for the unpleasant. Some say, Ravi Shankar challenged Vilayat Khan to a rematch and the latter calmed him down. The newspapers carried the report next day stating  Vilayat Khan played better than him. And to no one’s surprise, innumerable stories have been floating since then adding to the rift between the two maestros.

I was lucky to have sourced out (courtesy: kavitachhibber.com) two diametrically opposite narrations of this event, one from Vilayat Khan’s younger brother and Surbahar player Imrat Khan and the other from Ravi Shankar himself. Have a read but before you begin contemplating on who among the two is being truthful or is there an unspoken truth that neither of them have mentioned here; I would like you to simply imagine the moment, the mahaul of witnessing four musical greats performing together on the stage in the prime of their careers. It does not get more magical than this for sure!

Imrat Khan’s version:
I would like to set the record straight on that incident. Let me say this, Ravi Shankar would have been great at anything he tried his hand at. He was very bright, knew how to present himself, and he endeared himself to everyone with his diplomacy, unlike Bhaiya who spoke his mind very bluntly. But eventually, while Ravi Shankar made a name for himself, none of his students have turned out to be world class musicians.

Tell me one world class sitar player who can stand up and say I was trained by Ravi Shankar. The outstanding sitar players that you see today are my nephews Shujaat and Shahid and my sons, trained by bhaiya and me, and perhaps Budhaditya Mukherjee who is a student of our gharana.

Vilayat Khan
I also have to say this; there is no sitar player to touch my brother in the past 100 years, not even Ravi Shankar. The incident that Raviji spoke about to you happened in Delhi. Raviji was very well known then. He was also patronized by top notch business men, and the Nehru family, and the media too was very fond of him. When we arrived in Delhi for the festival, no one came to receive us and bhaiya was very upset. Later he was told he was to play with Ravi Shankar, and he said fine.

The news spread like wildfire and 4,000 people showed up to see this dialogue between the two. At that point Raviji said he will only play if Ali Akbar Khan plays with him since he was not used to playing without Ali Akbar Khan. As you know their sitar- sarod duet performances had won them a lot of acclaim, though there were people who felt that Ali Akbar Khan was more talented and they were doing well because of his presence. 

My brother retorted that then Imrat will play next to me. I was a young teenager but I guess bhaiya felt I was good enough to play with them. Then people told him, Imrat is a child, don’t drag him into this. You can manage so either play with the duo on your own or just back out. Bhaiya said fine I will play alone. Kishan Maharaj was on tabla. I was on tanpura.

The fact is my brother was the superior player that day. Whatever Raviji played my brother played faster and crystal clear. Then he said to Raviji “I have played whatever you have played; now I want you to play a taan that I’m going to play.” He played a taan which is very famous and is like the trademark of our gharana... It takes many many hours of practice for months to get it. Raviji tried and couldn’t do it. Ali Akbar tried and couldn’t do it either. Then my brother played it again and added more to it, and at that point pandemonium broke. People started roaring that Vilayat Khan had outshone Raviji and had the upper hand that day. The media that was so pro Raviji carried articles saying the same thing. Baba Allauddin Khan got very upset that his star disciples had been made to look so incompetent and yelled at my brother who respectfully took it.

Having said that I will say I have the utmost appreciation and respect for Ravi Shankar. He has single-handedly put Indian classical music on the map. My brother did feel resentment initially that though he was the better musician, Raviji was getting so much publicity, but towards the end of his life he knew that people knew he was the greatest and that gave him peace of mind. But as I said earlier, Ravi Shankar is a multitalented great man. He would have been famous in anything he tried his hand at, because he knew how to present himself in the best possible way.

Ravi Shankar’s version:
Vilayat Khan was a wonderfully gifted musician, and he passed away recently after a great career. The incident that you mentioned happened when we were playing at Red Fort and Ali Akbar Khan, and tabla maestro Kishan Maharaj were also on stage with us. All the famous musicians were there. I used to organize these musical events under the Jhankar Musical Circle Series and had been doing so for three-four years. That day I was also running a fever of 102 degrees. I was told we want to have all three of you Ali Akbar myself and Vilayat Khan, together on stage. I was a bit skeptical, but said fine. Vilayat Khan was very cordial and said, “Dada, prem se bajayenge” (we will play with love and affection) and I said fine. I also went along with whatever he wanted. "Let’s play raga Manj Khamaj," he said, and I said fine and played in whatever beat he wanted, just to keep the warmth and camaraderie. Nothing really happened that was unsavory, but the musicians from Delhi started cheering as he was tuning his sitar.
Ravi Shankar

The next day it all started off with the musicians from Delhi claiming Vilayat Khan had overshadowed me completely, his jhalla was superior, I couldn’t keep up with him etc, etc. I still didn’t dwell much on it until it came out in the newspapers in Bombay. I was very irritated then and in fact challenged Vilayat Khan openly to a rematch at a friend’s house. The legendary classical vocalist Amir Khan was there as were Ali Akbar Khan and Kishan Maharaj. Vilayat Khan immediately appeased me by saying "Dada, let’s not get in to this. People indulge in idle talk and unless you hear me say something in person, don’t go by hearsay." I let it go. He was such a wonderful musician, but whenever he played, the first thing he would do would be to make digs at me! I smile about it now, but it was a bit tiring

Sunday, April 17, 2011

Gharanas in Hindustani Classical Music - part II


 A brief list of today’s popular Gharanas in Hindustani Classical Music: 


Pandit D V Paluskar


Gwalior Gharana: This is the oldest among all the Khayal Gayaki (vocal) styles. Lucid and simple rendition of a composition is the distinctive style of this Gharana.
Founders: Ustad Hassu Khan, Ustad Haddu Khan and Ustad Nathu Khan
Exponents: Pandit Bal Krishna BaIchal Karanjikar, Pandit Vishnu Digambar Paluskar, Pandit Omkarnath Thakur, Veena Sahasrabuddhe and Malini Rajurkar
   



Ustad Faiyyaz Khan


Agra Gharana: The Agra Gharana places great importance on developing forcefulness and deepness in the voice making the notes sound powerful and resonant.
Founders: Ustad Haji Sujan Khan, Ustad Ghagghe Khuda Baksh
Exponents: Ustad Vilayat Hussain Khan, Ustad Faiyyaz Khan, Ustad Latafat Hussein Khan and Pandit Dinkar Kakini.

 



Pandit Bhimsen Joshi


Kirana Gharana: It derives its name from the birthplace of Abdul Karim Khan of Kirana near Kurukshetra. In the Kirana style of singing, the swara is used to create an emotional mood by means of elongation and use of tanas.
Founders: Ustad Abdul Karim Khan and Ustad Abdul Wahid Khan
Exponents: Hirabhai Barodekar, Pandit Bhimsen Joshi, Gangubai Hangal and Prabha Atre.

 



Kishori Amonkar

Jaipur Atrauli Gharana: The most distinctive feature of the Jaipur Gharana can be best described as its complex and melodic form which arises out of the involutedly and undulating phrases that comprise the piece.
Founders: Ustad Alladiya Khan
Exponents: Kesarbai Kerkar, Mogubai Kurdikar, Pandit Mallikarjun Mansur and Kishori Amonkar.

 

Ustad Nissar Hussain Khan

Rampur Sahaswan Gharana: The Rampur Sahaswan Gharana adds stress on the clarity of swara in the development and elaboration of a raga through a stepwise progression.
Founders: Ustad Inayat Khan
Exponents: Ustad Nissar Hussain Khan,
Ustad Ghulam Mustafa Khan, Ustad Rashid Khan, Sulochana and Brihaspati.

 




Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan


Patiala Gharana: Patiala Gharana is regarded as an offshoot of the Delhi Gharana. It is characterized by the use of complex layakari with the abundant use of bols and bol-taans.
Founders: Ustad Fateh Ali Khan and Ustad Ali Baksh
Exponents: Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali Khan, Pandit Ajoy Chakravarti, Ustad Raza Ali Khan and Parveen Sultana

 

Ustad Chand Khan


Delhi Gharana: The Delhi Gharana was represented by Tanras Khan and Shabbu Khan. The highlights of Delhi Gharana are its pleasing vistaar and exquisite compositions.
Founders: Ustad Mamman Khan
Exponents: Ustad Chand Khan, Ustad Nasir Ahmed Khan, Ustad Usman Khan, Ustad Iqbal Ahmed Khan and Pandit Krishna Bisht.

 


Ustad Amir Khan


Bhendi Bazaar Gharana: The most distinctive feature of the Bhendi Bazaar Gharana is the presentation of Khayal, which is open voice, using a-kar. Breath-control and singing of long passages in one breath is highly regarded in this Gharana.
Founders: Ustad Chajju Khan
Exponents: Ustad Amir Khan, Ustad Aman Ali Khan, Shashikala Koratkar and Anjanibai Malpekar.

 


Pandit Rajan Sajan Mishra

Benaras Gharana: The Benaras Gharana evolved as a result of great lilting style of Khayal singing known by Thumri singers of Benaras and Gaya.
Founders: Pandit Gopal Mishra

Exponents:  Girija Devi, Pandit Rajan Mishra and Pandit Sajan Mishra



Pandit Jasraj

Mewati Gharana: The Mewati Gharana gives importance to developing the mood of a raga through bhava pradhan. It also gives an equal importance to the meaning of the text.
Founders: Ustad Ghagge Nazir Khan
Exponents: Pandit Moti Ram, Pandit Mani Ram, Pandit Jasraj and Sanjeev Abhyankar

Saturday, April 16, 2011

Gharanas in Hindustani Classical Music

Spring is here, and it’s time for beautiful seasonal compositions like raga basant and raga bahar! And of course their numerous prakars like ragas basant bahar, basanti kedar, basanti kanhara, shudh bahar, hindol bahar and many more. But in this article today we do not plan to talk about seasonal ragas but a completely different facet of Hindustani Classical Music.

I’m sure most of you would have heard Pandit Bhimsen Joshi’s rendition of raga basant. If not at a live concert, you would’ve definitely heard his duet in the same raga with Manna Dey from the film, Basant Bahar. But his renditions sound too distinct to that of Pandit Mallikarjun Mansur’s. And both their renditions are way too different than Ustad Bade Ghulam Ali’s. If the composition is the same, then an individual style shouldn’t create such a stark difference. But it does. And the reasons behind it, lead me into the mysterious world of Gharanas in Hindustani Classical Music.

A Gharana is a school of a particular style of singing or playing instruments. The birth of Gharanas seeks its origin in the idea of preserving the tradition of music, original musical compositions and the distinctive style of its founder. Over the years, it is this quality which broadly determines a Gharana.  

Each Gharana has its unique discipline, system and technique. The character and style of traditionally disciplined music of a Gharana rest with one to three generations, and in due course some of the adept pupils add their own individual contribution combining with the incumbent style of performing. To add more, a Gharana also indicates a comprehensive musicological ideology; directly influencing the thinking, teaching, performance and appreciation of music.

The Gharana concept progressively gained more as the performers from various parts of India left behind their royal patronage and moved to urban centres in search of commercial success. In an attempt to retain their respective identities, they chose to be referred to by the regions they hailed from. Therefore even today, the names of many Gharanas refer to places in India. Some of the well known Gharanas in the Khayal system are Agra, Gwalior, Patiala, Kirana, Indore, Mewati, Rampur Sahaswan, Bhendi Bazar and Jaipur-Atrauli.

Being a comprehensive musicological ideology, the Gharanas often vary substantially from one another. The key differentiation between Gharanas is the manner in which the notes are sung. As Gharanas emerge from the creative style of a musical genius, he gives the existing form a completely new interpretation and cultivates new preferences. This new approach includes the tone of the voice, the pitch, the inflexions and the intonations, and the specific application of the various nuances. For example, the Kirana Gharana uses Ektaal (12-beat cycle) more frequently for Vilambit Khayal rendition while the Jaipur Gharana uses Teental (16-beat cycle) for transitioning from Vilambit to Drut laya which is not commonly featured in other Gharanas.

Apart from the Khayal tradition, Gharanas exist in Dhrupad as well as Thumri forms of singing. These Gharanas have moved from the temples to the royal courts of North India before dispersing to numerous locations in India including Benares, Lucknow, Mathura, Rampur, Jaipur, Varanasi, Darbhanga, Betia and Vishnupur.

The concept of Gharanas is not confined to vocal music alone. Although vocal music has always been the mainstay of Hindustani Classical Music, one of the most spectacular features of India's rich musical tradition is the evolution of a wide range of musical instruments and it is here where we find Gharanas in instrumental music especially with regards to Sitar, Sarod and Tabla.

As in its vocal counterpart, in the context of Indian classical instruments, the characteristics of a Gharana for each instrument includes the structure, tuning system and the tonality of the instruments teamed up with specific application of ‘tantrakari baaz’ or the vocabulary of the instrument. For example, Imdad Khan formed the Etawah Gharana, also known as the Imdadkhani Gharana which tutored musical geniuses such as Ustad Vilayat Khan, Ustad Rais Khan and Ustad Imrat Khan. Another such example is that of Ustad Allauddin Khan, who created the Seni Maihar Gharana which doled stalwarts like Pandit Ravi Shankar, Ustad Ali Akbar Khan and Pandit Nikhil Banerjee.

Conventionally, a Gharana is accepted by musicologists and musicians if it has existed for a minimum of three generations either within the family or through the historic Guru-Shishya parampara. Likewise, a musician may form a distinctive style by assimilating a variety of styles; and when his sons or disciples continue this style for three generations or more, a new Gharana is born.

Thus there has always been enough and more room for creative individuality within the tradition of a Gharana. Just as Vazebua, Omkarnath Thakur, Vinayak Rao Patwardhan and D.V. Paluskar were exponents of the same Gwalior Gharana but each of them had an entirely different style of singing. Similarly as referred to earlier, Pandit Ravi Shankar and Pandit Nikhil Banerjee have distinct styles of their own within the Seni Maihar framework.

The origin of the concept of Gharana lacks clarity. If we date back to the 16th century, we notice that the performing styles had already diversified into different Gharanas patronized in several princely courts. Amongst these, there were two major Gharanas that left a lasting impact on the Hindustani Classical Music system:

1. The Qawwal Gharana, founded and propagated by the multi-talented Amir Khusro. The Gharana included singers and Sitar players who were known to accompany singers during a Qawwali and Tarana performance. Later on, Shennai and Tabla players along with musicians who would accompany female singers and dancing girls in the Court too grew to be a part of this Gharana.

2. The Kalawanta Gharana, founded by renowned Dhrupad singer and composer Baiju Bawra. This Gharana included the singers of the Dhrupad style of music and the instrumentalists who played Saraswat Veena in accompaniment to vocal renditions.

Baiju Bawra was a contemporary of the famed Mian Tansen, one of the 'nine gems’ of Emperor Akbar's court and interestingly both these musicians were disciples of the same Guru; Swami Haridas, an illustrious saint from Brindavan.  This period is hailed as the golden age of Hindustani Classical Music as it was at this time when the system of Khayal and Dhrupad style of music attained perfection of expressions, and was held in the highest estimation by the royal courts of that period.

After the death of these stalwart musicians, many Gharanas representing their traditions sprung up. Some of the notable amongst them were the Seni Gharanas (from the family of Tansen): the first formed by Tansen’s youngest son Bilas Khan at the Delhi Darbar, the second formed by another son of Tansen named Surat Sen, whose descendants subsequently settled in Jaipur and the Gharana of Veena formed by Misri Singh, a celebrated Veena player, son of Maharaja Samokhan Singh and husband to Saraswati Devi, (Tansen’s daughter). Besides these three Seni Gharanas, the other famous Gharanas were the ones formed by Brija Chand and Suradas at Mathura and the Tilmandi Gharana of Dhrupad in Punjab formed by Chand Khan and Suraj Khan at that time.


Today, though the controlling style of each Gharana has witnessed a drop, it won’t be correct to say that they are losing popularity and following altogether. In fact the interest has increased as the number of students learning classical music is on a rise. Since the recent past, music teachers are experimenting with newer forms within the strict frameworks of various Gharanas. The Gharanas now are allowing enough freedom for creativity and individual experimentation and this feature is attracting new entrants to the system.

Many of the popular Gharanas may not be necessarily popular in their place of origin anymore but their influences surely have spread to other parts India and the World. Like Agra Gharana today is not widely held in Agra but we could find partisans of this style in cities like Mumbai and Delhi. And if that’s not all, some musicians across the world now are trying to revive old Gharanas by thoroughly studying the forms and compositions so that if people today cannot enjoy original recordings, they could at least experience them as re -creations.